Pakistan’s disinformation quandary
THE advent of technology has revolutionized the global distribution of news and information, including Pakistan. The internet and social media platforms have emerged as key players in disseminating information, enabling individuals to stay abreast of the latest developments with ease. Nonetheless, this transformation has also ushered in a surge of disinformation campaigns that seek to deceive the public, sow confusion and propagate particular agendas. This phenomenon has emerged as a significant apprehension for Pakistan, as the consequences of disinformation campaigns can be far-reaching, encompassing social, political and economic instability.
Disinformation, which refers to the intentional propagation of false information aimed at misleading or deceiving individuals, has emerged as a major predicament in Pakistan, propelled by the growing usage of the internet and social media platforms. Disinformation campaigns in the country are predominantly driven by political motivations, with the intent to sway public opinion, erode government credibility, or incite social unrest. Such campaigns are frequently disseminated through social media sites such as Facebook, Twitter and WhatsApp. Sensitive subjects, including religion, ethnicity and politics, are frequently targeted and the consequences can be dire, ranging from the incitement of violence to undermining national security.
In Pakistan, the proliferation of disinformation and misinformation has greatly influenced public perception of current events, as well as the country’s social, political and economic landscape. One of the major causes of this issue is the low levels of digital literacy among the general population. A significant portion of Pakistanis lack the critical thinking skills necessary to analyze information online, making them vulnerable to disinformation and misinformation.
Disinformation campaigns in Pakistan are politically motivated and often spread via social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter and WhatsApp. The prevalence of disinformation campaigns and distrust of the media has led to the polarization of society. People tend to gravitate towards sources that confirm their pre-existing beliefs and biases, creating echo chambers where individuals only consume information that aligns with their worldview. The impact of disinformation on Pakistani society is significant and affects everyone. This is not a problem limited to a specific group or political ideology but rather a broader societal issue that requires collective action to address.
To counter disinformation in Pakistan, the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) was enacted in 2016, penalizing those who spread false information through electronic channels. However, the law has been criticized for curbing free speech and infringing on the right to freedom of expression. Additionally, Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) established a web monitoring system in 2019 to detect objectionable online content, but it has faced accusations of censorship and limiting access to information, especially for legitimate dissenting voices and critical perspectives.
Countering disinformation in Pakistan necessitates a multi-pronged approach that engages a wide range of stakeholders. Here are some of the key steps that can be taken to counter disinformation campaigns effectively: Promote media literacy: Educating the public about the dangers of disinformation campaigns and promoting media literacy is crucial. This can be done through public campaigns, school programs and social media education programs.
Encourage responsible journalism: Media outlets in Pakistan should adopt responsible journalism practices to ensure that the information they report is accurate and verified. This can include fact-checking and verification procedures and ethical reporting practices. Promote independent media: Independent media outlets can help counter disinformation campaigns by providing accurate and unbiased information to the public. The government can support independent media outlets by providing financial assistance and regulatory support.
Encourage social media platforms to take responsibility: Social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter and YouTube have a responsibility to ensure that their platforms are not used to spread disinformation. The Pakistan government can work with these companies to develop policies and practices that limit the spread of false information. Develop fact-checking initiatives: Fact-checking initiatives can help counter disinformation campaigns by identifying false information and providing accurate information to the public. The government can support the development of fact-checking initiatives by providing funding and regulatory support.
Strengthen legal frameworks: The Pakistan government can strengthen legal frameworks to combat disinformation campaigns. This can include revising the PECA to ensure that it does not violate freedom of expression and developing new laws and regulations to address disinformation campaigns. Foster international cooperation: Disinformation campaigns are often global in nature and require international cooperation to address. The Pakistan government can work with international organizations and other countries to develop strategies and initiatives to counter disinformation campaigns.
Effectively countering disinformation campaigns in Pakistan necessitates a collaborative approach involving the government, media outlets, social media platforms, civil society and international organizations. Through cooperation and coordination, it is feasible to curb the spread of false information and ensure that the public can access precise and trustworthy information. This would help to combat disinformation campaigns and safeguard the integrity of public discourse in Pakistan.
—The writer is a researcher, based in Islamabad.
Email: [email protected]
