PAKISTAN’S political crisis has become a familiar spectacle. Every camp sees itself as the solution and others as the problem. Politicians accuse one another of corruption and disloyalty, yet refuse to discuss the country’s future together. They seek military or judicial intervention instead of dialogue. A favourable decision is applauded; an unfavourable one becomes interference. Politicians are not alone. The military faces questions about its political role, the judiciary about delayed justice, the civil service about poor governance and the media about bias. Everyone demands accountability from others. Who is willing to accept it?
At the Karachi Press Club, Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari called for a “political reset”, citing distrust of Parliament, political victimization, threats to judicial independence, pressure on the press, provincial rights and economic hardship. He accepted some responsibility. But diagnosis is not a cure. The PPP and other parties must explain what they intend to change and how they will uphold their principles when political interests shift. Parties reinterpret principles when moving between government and opposition. What was condemned yesterday is defended today. Changing tactics is legitimate; changing fundamental standards to suit power destroys credibility. Reform must begin within the parties themselves.
The Charter of Democracy signed by Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif in May 2006 was an attempt to establish common democratic ground. It addressed judicial independence, civilian governance, media freedom and resistance to unconstitutional intervention. Progress followed, but confrontation persisted. Before signing another charter, political leaders should explain why previous commitments were not honoured. Otherwise, the next agreement risks becoming another ceremonial photograph.
The PPP must also clarify its position on the 27th Constitutional Amendment. How does its support square with Bilawal’s criticism of its passage? Which provisions does it want changed and what will it do in Parliament? The same scrutiny must apply to the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf and others. Accountability begins at home.
A practical reset should start with structured negotiations among the government, opposition and major regional parties. The aim should be rules that outlast governments. A written charter should address credible elections, peaceful transfers of power, equal application of the law, the right to protest and safeguards against partisan use of state resources. Disagreements should be published, with civil society invited to contribute.
The parties must also practise what they preach: hold meaningful internal elections, disclose finances, allow dissent and adopt written policies. They should explain any change in position openly. A party unable to respect democracy within its own ranks cannot convincingly defend it nationally. Yet political agreement alone will not suffice. The Constitution already defines the broad limits of institutional authority. The challenge is enforcing them and penalizing violations. A reset must strengthen constitutional institutions, not establish another body above them.
The military’s primary responsibility is national defence and lawful assistance to civilian authorities. Its security expertise is essential, but elected representatives must determine political leadership. Politicians must likewise stop seeking unconstitutional backing against rivals. Effective parliamentary oversight is needed on both sides of this relationship. The judiciary must protect rights and deliver justice, not assume executive functions. Judicial independence must coexist with transparent appointments, timely decisions and accountability. Parliament should legislate; courts should exercise constitutional review. Each must respect the other’s mandate.
The civil service must serve the public rather than political personalities. The media must be free from intimidation while observing professional standards: verify allegations, distinguish news from opinion, correct errors and allow fair responses. Independence without responsibility can be as damaging as control without accountability.
A national charter should also reject character assassination. Politicians, judges, officers, officials and journalists should not face baseless accusations or labels of treason. This is not immunity from scrutiny: misconduct and abuse of power require investigation and lawful consequences. Evidence, not inflammatory speeches or media trials, should determine culpability. Political leaders must hold their own supporters to this standard.
Implementation needs deadlines. Any charter should also specify how breaches will be investigated and publicly reported, rather than merely promising better conduct. A joint parliamentary committee could present reform proposals within 90 days, identify responsible institutions and issue quarterly public progress reports. Relevant institutions, experts and civil society should be consulted, but legislation must remain Parliament’s responsibility. Ultimately, citizens will judge reform through better justice, public services and economic opportunity.
Bilawal’s proposal will mean something only if the PPP offers a concrete plan and all parties uphold the same standards in office and opposition. The military, judiciary, bureaucracy and media must accept scrutiny alongside authority. Pakistan does not need another rearrangement of power marketed as reform. It needs a change in behaviour. Constitutional boundaries already exist; they must be respected. Otherwise, faces and alliances will change, but the system will not. What is promised as a political reset may deliver another upset.
—The writer is contributing columnist, based in Canada.


















