Friday, November 20, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Friday, November 20, 2026

A Crime Without a Definition

A Crime Without A Definition
Pakistan's Section 26A punishes 'false information’ but never says what false means, or who gets to decide

On 29 July, the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) summoned a journalist over “false or fake information” under Section 26A of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA). The notice did not say which statement was false or what test applied. It listed the complainant only as “Through State” and gave him two days to appear. He went to the Islamabad High Court, which on 31 July directed the agency to give him the details of the allegations and disposed of his petition.

Parliament inserted Section 26A through the Prevention of Electronic Crimes (Amendment) Act, 2025, in January of that year. Human Rights Watch reports that authorities registered some 689 PECA cases between January and August 2025, many targeting journalists. In April 2026, the Interior Minister told the National Assembly that 187 cases had been registered under Section 26A alone.

The section punishes anyone who intentionally spreads, through an information system, content they know or have reason to believe is false or fake and likely to cause fear, panic, disorder or unrest. The penalty is up to three years in prison, a fine of up to Rs2 million, or both. The statute defines neither “false” nor “fake.” The line between reporting and a crime is not written into the law. The agency that issues the notices draws it afterwards.

On 4 August, thirteen organisations, including Article 19, Amnesty International and Lawyers for Lawyers, wrote to the government asking it to repeal Section 26A, withdraw notices based on protected journalism and introduce independent judicial safeguards. The letter also objected to the blocking of Al Jazeera’s website on 2 August, which the groups called retaliation for its coverage of protests in Pakistan-administered Kashmir, and to the imprisonment of two human rights lawyers over social media posts. The Foreign Media Facilitation Guidelines, 2026, require journalists working for foreign outlets, and the fixers and staff who assist them, to register with the Information Ministry and obtain a No Objection Certificate before reporting outside Islamabad, Lahore and Karachi.

Criminal law has a principle for what Section 26A gets wrong: nullum crimen sine lege certa, no crime without certain law. People must be able to know in advance what is forbidden, and an agency should not define the offence case by case. Pakistan’s courts have applied this reasoning to PECA before. On 8 April 2022, Islamabad High Court Chief Justice Athar Minallah struck down the PECA Amendment Ordinance, 2022, which had widened criminal defamation under Section 20, holding that it violated Articles 9, 14, 19 and 19-A of the Constitution. Challenges to the 2025 amendments are pending, but the courts have yet to rule on Section 26A itself.

The government is right that disinformation is a real problem. False claims travel faster than civil defamation law, built around individual complainants, can handle. A narrow criminal provision is not unreasonable. But a provision that defines falsity, sets a demanding mental element and sends fact-finding to a judge fills a gap. One that leaves all three to the investigating agency opens a void, and every future government inherits it. Section 26A already requires intent, yet “reason to believe” lowers that bar to something close to carelessness.

The court’s order in that case shows judges are watching, but correcting one notice at a time is a slow remedy for a flaw in the statute. Parliament wrote Section 26A and can repair it: define the terms, drop the “reason to believe” limb, and require a judge’s approval before the agency proceeds against anyone. How long that takes, or whether it happens, will show what kind of press Pakistan intends to have.

The author is a law student at the University of London.

Get Alerts