Saturday, November 21, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Saturday, November 21, 2026

The population clock nobody wants to hear

Lt Gen Omar Mahmood Hayat (r)

 

EVEN the most capable government would struggle with what Pakistan is facing. The 2023 census counted 241.49 million people, up from 132.35 million in 1998. The growth rate rose to 2.55% from 2.4% in 2017. That is the highest in the region and at this pace the population would double by 2050. Schools, clinics, jobs and homes cannot be built fast enough to keep up with that. So why did Pakistan fall behind Bangladesh, Iran and even India on family planning? There is no single culprit, but there is a pattern: we chose silence.

Governments of every stripe, civilian and military, treated population as too sensitive to touch. Programs were launched, starved of funds and quietly dropped when the government changed. The results show it. The contraceptive prevalence rate was 30% in 2007, 35% in 2012 and 34% in 2017 and the modern-method rate went from 22% to 25% and then stopped moving. Pakistan stood still for a decade while its population kept growing. The demand is there. 96% of married women know of at least one modern method, yet unmet need for family planning is 17.8% and there are an estimated 2.2 million unsafe abortions a year. These are women who want to plan their families and cannot. They are not women who refuse to.

What the neighbours did differently. Iran is the most striking case, because it is an Islamic republic. After the revolution, it encouraged big families and the population grew 3.9% a year between 1976 and 1986. Then it changed course. The national program was revived in 1989, with the backing of the dominant religious leaders. Fertility fell from about 7.0 births per woman in the early 1980s to 5.5 in 1988, 2.8 by the mid-1990s and near replacement level by 2000. Contraceptive use reached 74%. The programme worked because services reached the remotest villages through rural health houses.Bangladesh was poorer and more crowded than Pakistan and it still got there.

Contraceptive use climbed from 8% in the early 1970s to 64% in 2022. Its fertility rate has held at 2.3 children per woman since 2011. Pakistan’s is 3.6. Bangladesh did it by sending female field workers to women’s doorsteps, not by waiting for women to reach a clinic. The program also outlasted its governments. India is the messier comparison. Its national fertility rate has dropped to 2.0, below replacement and contraceptive use has risen from 54% to 67%. But the progress is uneven. Bihar (2.98) and Uttar Pradesh (2.35) are still above replacement level. India also carries the memory of coercive sterilization in the 1970s, which is a warning about what happens when voluntary choice is ignored. It isn’t religion. It’s delivery.Religion gets blamed too easily. Iran and Bangladesh are both Muslim societies and both talked to religious leaders instead of hiding from them. They framed family planning as protecting the health of mothers and children. Pakistan’s real failures are more ordinary. Primary healthcare is thin, especially in villages. The rural fertility rate is 3.9 against 2.9 in cities. About 30% of girls are married before 18. A girl who marries at 16 has no say in when or whether, she becomes a mother. Those are development failures and no poster campaign will fix them. What would work. First, political consensus. The 2019-2024 national action plan has been extended to 2030, with a target of cutting growth from 2.55% to 1.5%. Targets are easy to set. The test is whether the next government honors them. Population must be treated as a national security matter, above party politics.

Second, honest engagement with religious scholars. Pakistan should present family planning the way Iran did: as health, responsibility and the welfare of mothers and children. Third, investment in girls and women. Keeping girls in school, delaying marriage, putting a trained health worker within reach of every village and giving women paid work all lower fertility, in every country where it has been tried. Slogans don’t.

We keep asking why governments fail to deliver. But we have handed every government, good or bad, a demographic load that no system can carry indefinitely. Roughly 35 million people were added in under six years. No budget can keep up with that. The good news is that this can be changed. Iran went from 5.5 births per woman to near replacement level in about twelve years. Bangladesh did it with far fewer resources than we have. What they had and Pakistan has not yet shown, was the political nerve to say the word “population” out loud and keep funding the answer. Until we do, we will keep blaming governments for failing at a task we never gave them the tools to complete.

—The writer is Ex-Chairman, National Disaster Management Authority.

 

Get Alerts