Saturday, November 21, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Saturday, November 21, 2026

When understanding earns the marks

When Understanding Earns The Marks
Sadia Naz

OR students preparing for board examinations, one question often dominates: what is likely to appear in the paper? It shapes revision, tuition and, too often, classroom teaching. Pakistan’s examination reforms face a demanding challenge: can they make understanding a subject more rewarding than predicting examination questions?

The answer will influence far more than results. Examinations determine what teachers emphasize, what parents invest in and what students believe learning requires. If memorized answers consistently earn the highest marks, rote learning remains a rational strategy. When papers require explanation, interpretation and application, educational incentives begin to change.

This relationship between assessment and learning lies at the heart of the Inter Boards Coordination Commission’s (IBCC) reform agenda. The objective is to translate national agreement into better question papers, consistent marking and qualifications that reflect students’ achievements more meaningfully.

The IBCC Act, 2023, established the Commission as a statutory institution, strengthening its role in coordinating examination boards. Working under the Ministry of Federal Education and Professional Training, IBCC promotes common standards while addressing differences in institutional resources and capacity. Under Executive Director Dr Ghulam Ali Mallah, assessment reform has been linked with professional development and digital transformation. The Model Assessment Framework for Grades IX–XII provides direction for examinations that measure not only students’ ability to recall facts but also their capacity to interpret information, explain relationships and apply knowledge to unfamiliar situations.

Remembering remains essential, but understanding is demonstrated when students use concepts to solve problems or support conclusions with evidence. Such questions must be carefully designed. Complex language, excessive length or obscure content do not necessarily measure higher-order thinking; they may simply create confusion.

Subject-specific assessment frameworks and model question papers help translate reform into practice. They guide teachers in developing students’ skills, support paper setters in aligning questions with learning outcomes and help students understand conceptual assessment.

However, transforming model papers into routine board examinations requires trained professionals. Paper setters must produce clear, balanced questions, reviewers must identify ambiguity and examiners need marking schemes that recognize valid reasoning, even when answers differ from textbook wording.

IBCC’s capacity-building initiatives with the Aga Khan University Examination Board support this transition through workshops on conceptual examinations and assessment frameworks. Their effectiveness will depend on practical application, institutional follow-through and continuous review of examination practices.

The transition to a new grading system also requires clear communication. Students and parents must understand how grades are reported and what changes mean for further education. Technology can further improve examination management through secure question banks, digital workflows and on-screen marking. Yet these tools require trained staff, reliable procedures and proper oversight. Equally important, boards with limited resources must receive support to ensure reforms are implemented fairly nationwide.

Pakistan’s examination reform will earn public trust through students’ experiences. Its real success will come when a learner discovers that explaining an idea convincingly earns more credit than reproducing a rehearsed passage. That is when national policy begins to transform the meaning of success in the classroom.

—The writer is Deputy Director IBCC, Islamabad

([email protected])

 

Get Alerts