Thursday, November 19, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Thursday, November 19, 2026

Between Public Duty and the Politics of Perception Conduct, privacy and the pursuit of popularity in Pakistan’s bureaucracy

Apni Chhat Apna Ghar Maryam Nawaz Makes History With Global Recognition

A public servant is defined not merely by the office one holds, but by the responsibility that comes with it. Public service means placing citizens’ welfare, institutional integrity and the common good at the heart of governance. A public servant does not stop being one when the workday ends. The Supreme Court recently reaffirmed this principle in a ruling with implications beyond the case itself.

On Nov. 4, 2026, a Bench led by Justice Ayesha Malik upheld the compulsory retirement of a former government employee accused in departmental proceedings of setting his wife on fire. Although a criminal court acquitted him, he argued that the matter was a private domestic affair unrelated to his official responsibilities. The Court rejected this argument. Justice Shahid Waheed held that grave off-duty conduct could constitute misconduct, and that criminal acquittal did not automatically negate departmental findings. “Respect for women,” the judgment observed, “is not a private virtue that a civil servant may practise or neglect as he pleases.”

The case concerned domestic violence, but its principle has wider relevance. Public servants entrusted with state authority must demonstrate integrity and sound judgment. Their private lives are not public property, but neither are they beyond scrutiny. When personal conduct undermines public confidence or brings an office into disrepute, it becomes a legitimate institutional concern.

Pakistan’s administrative framework recognises this distinction. The Government Servants (Conduct) Rules, 1964, establish standards of official conduct, while the Civil Servants (E&D) Rules, 2020, provide a framework for addressing misconduct. The Conduct Rules restrict unauthorised disclosure of official information and public statements that may embarrass the government.

In Aug. 2021, the Establishment Division extended this approach to the digital sphere, directing government servants not to participate in media platforms without prior government permission. It also warned that administrators of online groups where violations occurred could face departmental proceedings. A Sept. 2024 circular further prohibited government employees from posting political or religious opinions, forwarding political content, displaying political affiliations or promoting commercial interests online, warning that such conduct could constitute misconduct.

These instructions are sometimes portrayed as resistance to technological change. However, they also recognise social media’s constructive potential, encouraging government organisations to use digital platforms for public feedback and complaints, provided they are appropriately moderated. The distinction is between institutions communicating with citizens and individual public servants using official standing to cultivate personal followings.

Social media rewards what can be filmed, but much of effective public administration cannot. A price-control raid, dramatic rescue or confrontation with a shopkeeper can generate engaging videos. Clearing backlogs, improving procurement procedures and training frontline staff rarely attract similar attention. Officers pursuing online visibility may favour shareable activities over less visible governance improvements, diverting attention from meaningful reform.

The consequences extend further. Online followings can become constituencies of their own, encouraging officials to judge decisions by their digital appeal. A system founded on political neutrality risks becoming a marketplace of personal brands, where officers cultivate audiences useful to political patrons or career ambitions. Citizens also suffer when people filmed during raids, hearings, or complaint proceedings become online content without consent. Public office loses dignity when citizens become props in an individual’s pursuit of popularity.

The Punjab government, led by Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz, has introduced measures reinforcing professional discipline and distinguishing institutional communication from personal publicity.

In Sept. 2024, after videos circulated showing police personnel on duty, the chief minister directed restrictions on their social media use. Punjab Police subsequently required official communication to pass through authorised departmental platforms and warned against using official resources for personal aggrandisement.

In Sept. 2025, S&GAD issued province-wide guidelines prohibiting public officials from using government activities, official engagements or individual achievements for personal glorification and self-promotion, warning of disciplinary action.

Punjab has also recognised the constructive potential of digital platforms. Launched in Feb. 2026, the Talk 2 CM Portal provides citizens with a structured channel to submit suggestions, ideas and feedback directly to the Chief Minister’s Office. Together, these measures emphasise that social media should serve public communication, accountability and citizen participation, not personal celebrity.

A useful benchmark remains the United Kingdom’s Seven Principles of Public Life, introduced in 1995 by Lord Nolan’s Committee on Standards in Public Life: selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership.

Selflessness is particularly relevant in the social media age. Public servants must act in the public interest rather than for personal gain. In an economy driven by attention and popularity, visibility itself can become a form of personal gain.

This does not mean public servants should remain invisible. Citizens benefit when administrations publicise vaccination campaigns, respond to complaints and explain public services. The essential question is who the communication serves and who receives the credit. Institutional communication informs citizens; self-promotion enhances an officer’s profile using the authority of public office.

Blanket prohibitions may be easy to announce but difficult to enforce. Clearer, consistently applied standards would be more effective. Official communication should use moderated and archived departmental accounts, with officers quoted where necessary rather than routinely featured. Citizens should not be filmed during raids, hearings or complaint proceedings without informed consent. Body cameras and official records should strengthen accountability, not provide online entertainment.

Personal accounts should not display uniforms, official vehicles or government business, consistent with existing instructions. Performance assessments should recognise files processed, complaints resolved and services improved, not followers or views accumulated. Digital conduct should feature in civil service induction and professional training, reinforced by senior officials setting an example.

The same principle of proportionate accountability should apply to private conduct. An officer’s family life, home and personal choices remain their own unless conduct becomes sufficiently grave to compromise the trust attached to public office, as the apex court found in the aforementioned case. The standard is not personal perfection, but conduct consistent with the responsibilities and dignity of public office.

Ultimately, a public servant’s most important audience is the citizen waiting at the counter, not the follower scrolling through a feed. The SCP has reminded public officials that their responsibilities do not necessarily end at the workplace. Social media presents a related test: whether they remember that public office is held in trust for citizens, not owned as a platform for personal promotion.

The finest public servants will be recognised—but for the services they deliver, not the videos they make go viral.

 

Get Alerts