Friday, November 20, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Friday, November 20, 2026

Strong children require strong child rights institutions

World Children’s Day — 20 November 2026

CHILDREN rights cannot be secured through legislation, policy declarations, ratification of international conventions or symbolic commemorations such as World Children’s Day alone.Their meaningful protection requires strong, independent, transparent and accountable institutions that not only work towards fulfilling children’s rights but also bring about progressive and measurable improvements in their lives.

Recognizing this fundamental reality, civil society in Pakistan has chosen the theme for World Children’s Day 2026: “Strong Children Require Strong Child Rights Institutions.” The message behind this theme is clear: children cannot fully enjoy their rights unless the institutions entrusted with protecting those rights are themselves independent, competent, transparent and accountable.

Child rights institutions: the backbone of child safeguarding: Child rights institutions are not merely administrative bodies. They are essential pillars of an effective child protection system. Their responsibilities extend beyond responding to individual violations. They monitor the implementation of child rights legislation, receive and examine complaints, identify systemic weaknesses, facilitate access to justice, advise governments on child-friendly policies and hold public authorities accountable for their obligations.

The United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child, through General Comment No. 2 (2002), has emphasised the importance of independent national human rights institutions in promoting and protecting children’s rights. Similarly, the Paris Principles, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1993, provide internationally recognized standards concerning the independence, mandate, pluralism, composition and effective functioning of national human rights institutions. Consequently, an effective national child rights institution must have a clear statutory mandate, professionally competent leadership, adequate financial and administrative resources, institutional autonomy and transparent merit-based appointment procedures. Without these safeguards, even a well-designed institution becomes ineffective.

Pakistan has established child rights commissions, ombudsman institutions and child protection bodies at federal and provincial levels. Among these institutions, the National Commission on the Rights of Child (NCRC) occupies a particularly important position as a national statutory body responsible for promoting, protecting and monitoring children’s rights. However, recent developments concerning appointments and selective extensions within the NCRC have raised serious questions about institutional independence, transparency, equality and merit-based governance.

NCRC appointment controversy: Merit, equality and transparency at stake: Following the completion of the NCRC’s second term on 10 April 2026, the Federal Government, through the Ministry of Human Rights, extended the tenure of the Chairperson and two Members representing Sindh/Minorities and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa for another term. However, the remaining three Member positions representing Punjab, Islamabad Capital Territory and Balochistan were not granted similar extensions. Instead, these positions were advertised for fresh appointments.

The process adopted for retaining certain officeholders while initiating fresh appointments for other positions has raised legitimate questions about the extension criteria, considerations and appointment procedures underlying the administrative decisions. In particular, it is important to establish whether all the incumbents of NCRC’s second term were assessed against consistent, objective and legally prescribed standards for granting extension.

Although the NCRC Act 2017 provides for the possibility of extension. Therefore, the mere grant of an extension does not, by itself, establish illegality. The more fundamental question is whether the discretion to grant or withhold extensions was exercised lawfully, fairly, consistently and transparently, in accordance with the terms and conditions governing the appointment and extension as mentioned in Federal Govt. Management Position Scale (MP Scale) Policy 2020.

Another important consideration concerning public confidence in the NCRC is the perceived political affiliation of its leadership. The incumbent Chairperson of NCRC has the political background, as she previously held elected positions in the Senate and National Assembly, and currently working on various executive and political positions in present government alongside other non-governmental employments. These circumstances have prompted concerns within civil society about the potential influence of political considerations in decisions concerning the extension of the tenure of Chairperson and her two favorite Members.

Meanwhile, the recruitment process for three remaining Member positionshas generated further questions about the timely completion of appointments and the public disclosure of their status. According to the information available to civil society, the shortlisting process had been completed by the Ministry of Human Rights, but the appointments remained pending. Seven months have been passed to the completion of NCRC’s second term, but these important positions are still unfilled. Such delays undermine the Commission’s representative composition, institutional capacity and effective functioning. They also raise questions about the consistency and transparency of the appointment process. The concerns highlighted above need be examined within the applicable legal framework and constitutional principles of lawful treatment, equality and non-discrimination, particularly Articles 4, 18, 25 and 27 of the Constitution of Pakistan.

Civil society’s response: From advocacy to judicial intervention: Recognizing the potential implications of above developments, child rights activists, human rights defenders and civil society organizations across Pakistan initiated a collective advocacy campaign seeking transparent and merit-based appointments within the NCRC.

The concerns were initially raised through media engagement, public discussions and an online campaign. Subsequently, a formal representation was submitted to the Prime Minister of Pakistan, requesting government intervention and seeking the suspension or reconsideration of the disputed extensions. The representation received the endorsement of approximately 350 child rights activists and civil society organizations. It was also shared with relevant parliamentarians, heads of public institutions, foreign diplomats and United Nations agencies in Pakistan. Despite this collective effort, civil society expressed dissatisfaction with the absence of an effective response from the relevant authorities.

The matter was subsequently brought to the attention of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child. Following consideration, the Committee indicated that civil society should first seek a response from the State and exhaust available domestic avenues of redress before returning to the Committee for further consideration.

Consequently, civil society pursued judicial intervention through a writ petition before the Islamabad High Court, challenged the disputed extensions and seeking judicial scrutiny of the exercise of administrative discretion. The 114-page petition, filed in the nature of quo warranto proceedings, raises questions concerning the legality, transparency and fairness of the extension process including unlawful holding of the office by NCRC’s Chairperson and two Members. On 07 September 2026, the Court has admitted the matter for consideration within the scope of judicial review of administrative actions and issued notices to the respondents and sought their responses. The proceedings remain pending, and the allegations and legal questions raised in the petition are yet to be finally determined by the Court.

Political influence must not compromise credibility of child rights institutions: The credibility of a child rights institution depends fundamentally on its independence, impartiality and professional integrity. Political affiliations, personal preferences and administrative convenience must never displace legally prescribed eligibility criteria, objective assessments and transparent appointment procedures. A politically influenced or institutionally weakened commission cannot effectively scrutinise government policies, investigate systemic failures or challenge violations involving powerful individuals and public authorities. Conversely, an independent and professionally competent institution can serve as an effective mechanism for accountability, prevention, protection and access to justice.

What must Pakistan do to strengthen child rights institutions? World Children’s Day 2026 provides an opportunity for Pakistan to move beyond symbolic celebrations and adopt following institutional reforms;

(i). Ensure transparent and merit-based appointments: Appointments to child rights commissions must follow clearly defined eligibility criteria, transparent selection procedures and impartial assessments of professional competence, relevant experience and integrity. Consistent standards must apply to all candidates and officeholders, including decisions concerning extensions and reappointments.

(ii). Ensure meaningful representation and institutional continuity: The composition of NCRC consists of provincial representation, gender balance, minority representation and children participation. Vacancies should be filled through timely and transparent procedures to prevent it from becoming ineffective.

(iii). Strengthen parliamentary and institutional oversight: Parliament, the judiciary and relevant oversight bodies must ensure that public appointments and administrative decisions comply with applicable legislation and constitutional principles of equality, fairness, transparency and due process.

(iv). Protect institutional independence: Child rights institutions must be able to perform their statutory functions without political pressure, administrative interference or personal influence. Their leadership must have the institutional autonomy necessary to independently scrutinize government policies, programmes and performance concerning children’s rights.

(v). Promote meaningful child participation: Children must be provided with genuine opportunities to express their views and participate in decisions affecting their lives. Institutions should develop accessible, safe and child-friendly mechanisms through which children can communicate their concerns, seek assistance and contribute to policy development.

(vi). Provision of adequate financial and professional resources: Independent institutions require sufficient financial, administrative and human resources to fulfil their mandates effectively. Therefore, qualified investigators, legal professionals, researchers, child protection specialists and other technical experts must be provided to these institutions to perform their functions effectively.

(vii) Restore public confidence in the NCRC: The Commission must function as an independent national statutory institution guided by its domestic legal mandate and international human rights obligations rather than political or personal preferences. Resolving the current NCRC appointment controversy through lawful, transparent and impartial procedures is essential to restoring public confidence in its leadership and institutional credibility.

Conclusion: Strong institutions, a bright future for children: On this World Children’s Day, Pakistan’s political leadership, parliament, judiciary, human rights institutions, civil society, development partners and international community must reaffirm a shared commitment to protecting the credibility and independence of institutions entrusted with safeguarding children’s rights. Strong children require strong child rights institutions. And strong child rights institutions require independence, integrity, transparency and accountability!

—The writer is lawyer, writer & child rights expert former Programme Policy Advisor at National Commission on the Rights of Child, Govt of Pakistan, Islamabad.

([email protected])

Get Alerts