Zeenia Satti
PROVINCIAL restructuring has become the most contentious issue among Pakistan’s ruling elite. It is disappointing to see that in this matter, the difference between highly educated and mildly educated politicians is hardly visible. Bilawal, an Oxford-educated mind, declared that Sindh is his Mother and will not allow the division of his mother at any cost!? One expects from him arguments, not emotive outburst. He never describes the loss Sindhis will incur if province is multiplied. He sheds no light on how traders, students, political parties, voters and the legislative assemblies will suffer. He doesn’t tell how tax collection is rendered more difficult and governance more challenging. He doesn’t tell how healthcare, education, disaster management, waste management, police, judiciary, food system, governance, election management etc., will become unmanageable if Sindh is multiplied into two or three provinces.
Unlike India, Pakistan is fortunate to have many educated politicians trained in the best universities in the world. Benazir Bhutto studied at Oxford and Harvard. Bilawal graduated from Oxford. Aseefa Bhutto from University College London, Sherry Rehman from Smith College Massachusetts, Khurram Dastgir from Caltech USA, Shahid Khaqan from George Washington, USA – the list continues with the PPP standing out as the party possessing the most educated leadership.
AI describes the difference between educated and uneducated politicians as follows; Difference lies in policy making capabilities and standards of perception of issues. Educated leaders are better at critical thinking and general knowledge that helps them analyze complex systems and evaluate the comparative benefits of systems in a dispute. Educated politicians have the ability to adapt to new trends and new technologies and are less conservative in their positions than uneducated politicians. First hand technical reviews become easier for educated leaders compared to uneducated leaders. Educated leaders can build better support systems among advisors and experts because they can discern ability in others while less educated are more comfortable with primordial loyalty, family ties and nepotism instead of higher ability. Examples abound of great leaders who lacked formal education and educated leaders who failed their country, yet the qualitative difference between good and bad leaders puts enlightenment and education at the center.
Instead of mobilizing opinion through informative discourse on administrative overhaul, our leaders are reticent. They are deciding our political existence through primordial instincts, not on scientific and rational grounds. Both sides of the divide on new provinces are failing to educate masses on merits and demerits of Pakistan’s provincial overhaul. PML-N does not have as highly qualified a leadership as PPP, but has decades of governance experience yet its leaders remain silent on the issue. PTI is incarcerated. Fazalur Rehman is inciting Pakistanis to violence. Jamat-e-Islami holds rallies on both national and global issues but does not discuss how Pakistan will fare with more provinces.
The matter is so important to our existence that we will not allow it to be ‘tackled’ in the manner a foreign policy issue is tackled by a handful of diplomats at MOFA – behind closed doors. Everything we are, we do and want for ourselves, our community, our nation state depends on the decisions taken on the issue of administrative overhaul of our system. System is made of us, to serve our needs. Our leaders must tell us where they stand on the issue of restructuring of provinces in a manner that does not make mockery of our worth as thinking beings and theirs as worthy leaders.
Sherry Rehman’s Jinnah Institute regularly convenes seminars yet none is convened on subject of provincial restructuring. PPP was injected a short in the arm when the fresh blood of an intelligent Oxford graduate mingled with the old guard as its leader. Bilawal surprised us with his refined and erudite talk upon assuming chairpersonship of PPP at age eighteen. Now he talks about the crucial issue of Pakistan’s administrative overhaul in a tribal manner. What kind of environment prevails within the cadre of our political parties that they stultify fresh energy instead of letting it revitalize the party?
We demand better performance from our leaders as they discuss our needs and decide how to fulfil them. If politicians fail us, will the ISPR please step in the void and convene a meeting of civil society representatives to discuss live on TV the issue of new provinces? I wrote on the need for division of Punjab after repeatedly suffering tiring commute from northern Punjab to Lahore during my work as community server. After six hours journey, I would suffer prolonged rush hours upon arrival. I longed for convenient access to provincial headquarters. Now that our state is beginning to discuss the matter, please give us educated arguments for and against the proposal, not emotive appeals.
—The writer is CEO at Pakistan’s People Led Disaster Management.


















