FEDERAL Minister for Planning Prof. Ahsan Iqbal, who is known for his moderating views on issues of governance and economic development, has lent further credibility to widely circulating reports about creation of new provinces before the Senate elections in March 2027. In an interview, he has also increased the tally of the proposed provinces from 12 to 14, pointing out he has heard of a plan for 14 provinces in Pakistan, with four each in Punjab and Sindh and three each in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. He argued that the question of new provinces will have to be resolved before the Senate elections; otherwise the new provinces might have reservations about their proportionate representation in the upper house.
The remarks of the Minister, together with a host of statements by other members of the Federal Cabinet, are indicative of a sort of emerging consensus among the ruling PML(N) on the critical issue of new administrative units. However, the PPP, which is the major coalition partner of the PML(N), is dead against the idea to the extent of division of Sindh, the main support base for the party. The simmering differences between the two main parties sharpened on Tuesday when the PPP leader Bilawal Bhutto Zardari delivered a hard-hitting statement during his media interaction at Karachi Press Club. He called for a ‘system reset’ but wanted that the process should be political and not non-political, warning ‘forced division’ of Sindh could lead to blood-shed on the streets of Karachi and the issue might have its impact on other urban centres of the province. Bilawal also emphasized that the question of creation of new provinces should be sorted out in a constitutional manner and not otherwise. His bitter remarks evoked strong response from Federal Minister for Information and Broadcasting Attaullah Tarar who said that a referendum was a legal and constitutional method of gauging public opinion on new provinces, adding that no political party should have reservations regarding it. He reminded the PPP leader that political parties (including PML-N and PPP) have been part of the system for decades and are, therefore, also responsible for its weaknesses. He said that to “enjoy the perks” being in power and also do opposition amounted to having a “double standard”. PPP, being a firm believer of democracy and constitutionalism, is talking in terms of a mechanism devised in the Constitution for creation of new provinces involving consent of the relevant provincial assemblies. However, a referendum, as pointed out by the Information Minister, is also a procedure envisaged in the Constitution to gauge the public opinion on a given question.
A democratic party ought not to oppose any move aimed at seeking the opinion of the masses on a very important issue, which could transform the way the people are governed. Why should a political party be apprehensive of the public opinion? Instead of opposing the referendum, all political parties should reach out to the voters to convince them about the logic of supporting or opposing the plan for creation of new provinces. As Bilawal was opposing plans for a referendum, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) once again called for a nationwide referendum on the creation of new administrative units, proposing that the exercise be held before the start of 2027 to allow people to decide the future administrative structure of the country. The party argued that the creation of new administrative units should not be treated as a political controversy, arguing that public opinion must determine whether additional provinces or administrative units are needed. Otherwise too, PPP’s position is not tenable as it has no objection to creation of new provinces in the three other federating units, which is a discriminatory approach. The new units may or may not produce the desired results in terms of delivering better services to the people but it is also a reality that the political parties have shown their inability to devolve powers and resources as per true spirit of the democratic governance. Then how the process of ‘reset’, which Bilawal too pleads for, is to be realized?















