THOUGH President Trump has ruled out to use the nuclear option against Iran, strategists argue that President Trump’s intermittent threat to use the option of an ultimate weapon against Iran was and is by no means calibrated deterrence—rather, it sets a dangerous precedent that breaks down strategic maturity. This observation/argument is further supported by Richard Haass insightful article in the Project Syndicate, ‘’Trump’s Risky War of Choice in Iran (1 March 2026). Haass argues, this was not a war of necessity but ‘’a war of choice’’—a preventive war where ‘’ Iran posed no imminent threat to vital US interests’’. Needless to say, if deterrence fails, executing or invoking a threat doesn’t simply achieve a political goal, rather, it ensues total ruin for both sides. Thus, relying on inherently irrational act is not a stable strategy, but a systemic failure of rational statecraft.
Analytically examining, Trump’s two-pronged approach toward Iran combined diplomatic engagement with aggressive rhetoric and policy shifts, exemplified by withdrawing from the JCPOA and adopting a ‘maximum pressure’ campaign. Further, owing to its escalatory risks and disregard for multilateral agreements, the Trump’s strategy underwent severe foreign policy miscarriages. Unlike traditional diplomacy emphasizing dialogue and verification, Trump prioritized unilateral pressure, increasing regional tensions. Thus, this strategy undermined trust, limited negotiation avenues, and heightened fears of nuclear proliferation. Arguably, the contrast lies not in diplomacy vs. aggression per se, but in methods: one reliant on international cooperation, the other on coercion and brinkmanship.
And yet, there can be no denying the fact that in terms of US strategic engagement with Iran, the Islamabad Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) represented a balanced strategic opportunity where the US engaged constructively with Pakistan to foster regional stability and peace efforts, particularly in the context of a broader Middle East diplomacy. As ill- conceived US policy would have it, influential pro-Israel neoconservative factions within the US government prioritized hardline policies over diplomatic engagement, undermining potential progress.
Peace and Conflict Studies observers point out that the administration’s dismissal of traditional bureaucratic channels and multilateral diplomacy leaves it prone to erratic shifts between sudden military escalation and negotiating memorandum of understanding, thereby deliberately rendering the MoU as an inconclusive reconciliatory mechanism. And yet, Pakistan is fully committed to playing its mediatory role. Moreover, Trump’s escalating rhetoric—marked by assertions that Iran faces a choice between compliance or severe consequences amid active regional hostilities—kept the bilateral axis perched uncomfortably close to an open conflict rather than a stable deterrence.
Therefore, several moderate Republicans and seasoned diplomats have publicly opposed escalating US-Iran tensions, advocating for diplomacy over military confrontation. They have been arguing that Trump’s nuclear threats against Iran risked provoking a catastrophic conflict without securing long-term security gains. These voices vehemently emphasize the importance of multilateral engagement, arms control agreements, and de-escalation to prevent regional instability. Their stance reflects a broader consensus in foreign policy circles that restraint and negotiation are more effective than coercive posturing, especially when nuclear risks are involved.
In this vein, US Vice President JD Vance publicly attributed the Republican Party’s midterm setbacks directly to voter frustration over the war in Iran and rising living costs. On the contrary, President Donald Trump and Secretary of State Marco Rubio defended the military campaign, maintaining that it was necessary to prevent Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon. On the other hand, in his latest comment, former Democratic US President Barack Obama has alleged the Trump administration of starting an unjust war against Iran since no evidence supports that Iran has had a nuclear bomb. Also, observers note that hardliners on both sides exploit military pressure and public rhetoric, creating a danger where strikes could launch mid-negotiation.
It is an agreed fact that multilateral international mediation helps stabilize expectations and manage economic pressures, such as oil network targeting and UN snapback deadlines. Therefore, it is fittingly argued that purely bilateral demands from Washington or Tehran are often stalled due to maximalist conditions (such as port blockades, sanctions relief, and regional proxy restrictions). Additionally, involving international partners allows for phased compromises, economic escrow channels, and verified de-escalation.
Recent surveys indicate that a majority of Americans have consistently opposed President Trump’s proposed use of nuclear weapons against Iran, reflecting broad public caution toward nuclear escalation. This resistance underscores a preference for diplomatic solutions and highlights concerns about the catastrophic consequences of nuclear war. Also, the findings suggest that while the Israeli- backed neocons may support strong stances against Iran, public opinion strongly rejects the use of nuclear options, even in extreme scenarios. Obviously, such sentiment aligns with long-standing American foreign policy principles emphasizing deterrence over first use. Thus, multilateral diplomacy is essential to prevent catastrophic escalation, as unilateral actions, like a potential nuclear threat from any leader. By engaging international allies, institutions like the UN and mechanisms such as arms control treaties, diplomatic pressure can de-escalate tensions, verify compliance, and enforce norms against nuclear use. True, collective action enhances legitimacy, reduces miscalculation, and strengthens deterrence through unified resolve.
In conclusion, Trump’s strategy to shift deterrence from passive to compellence failed because the war with Iran was never a war of necessity, but a war of choice since diplomacy was still available. Trump’ s failed deterrence has significantly fosters the argument that relying on a broader consensus ensures accountability and prevents rash decisions driven by political rhetoric. Still, better late than never, instead of relying on brinkmanship-cum- nuclear blackmailing vis-a- vis Iran, Washington must pursue a strategy of peace diplomacy to avert the harrowing global consequences of this war. It is necessary that the US leadership must show statesmanship and pragmatism through a diplomatic strategy of gradual incrementalism toward Iran by restoring America’s image as a poised and indispensable global partner for peace and prosperity.
—The writer is an independent IR & International Law analyst.


















