THE provinces issue is back once again regarding more provinces. The ruling PML-N has largely remained vague, with some indications that the Punjab govt is not keen on creating new provinces before the next general elections. The PPP also has reservations, rejecting any move to divide Sindh. Legal and constitutional experts have pointed out that a referendum would not be legally binding and cannot circumvent constitutional procedure required to create new provinces.
However, the legal experts are divided on the question of referendum. The real issue is not whether a referendum should be held but why new provinces are needed in the first place and how they would serve the public interest. Better governance and improved fiscal management are among the usual arguments advanced in their favour. Some observers believe that a larger number of provinces could benefit the country as a whole and make administration more responsive. Others see the proposal as an attempt to cut established political parties down to size by giving smaller parties greater political space and ending the entrenched fiefdoms of mainstream parties.
More importantly, any restructuring must be assessed against its financial implications. A report by the Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) estimates that the net additional recurring cost of creating new provinces could range from Rs46.9 billion to as much as Rs730.3 billion. The report also warns that additional provinces could place considerable pressure on fiscal resources of smaller units, particularly those with lower NFC allocations and limited revenue-generation capacity.
A greater share of their available resources could end up being consumed by recurring government expenditure, leaving even less for development and the improvement of public services. These are not minor considerations in a country already struggling with fiscal constraints and inadequate public services. If the objective is genuinely to improve governance and bring the state closer to citizens, there may be a more practical solution available at present.
An empowered and uniform local government system, protected through a constitutional amendment, could deliver many of the administrative benefits being promised through the creation of new provinces. Local governments are better placed to respond to citizens’ everyday needs, address municipal problems and improve service delivery, provided they have meaningful authority and adequate financial resources. The priority should be to make the existing system work for citizens before embarking on another potentially expensive and divisive exercise in restructuring the state.
—The writer is contributing columnist, based in Lahore.

















