Book Review Carving value: Pakistan’s stone & mineral economy

Beyond selective criticism

CARVING Value: Pakistan’s Stone and Mineral Economy is a timely contribution to the discourse on Pakistan’s natural resource potential and economic transformation. The book examines one of the country’s most underdeveloped yet promising sectors, the stone and mineral economy and argues that Pakistan’s primary challenge is not the absence of resources, but the inability to convert geological wealth into sustainable economic value.

Moving beyond a conventional discussion of mining, the book presents the sector as an integral part of broader economic development, linking minerals with exports, employment generation, SME growth, technology adoption, regional development, and institutional reform. Its central argument is both simple and compelling: natural resources do not automatically create prosperity. Economic value emerges when resources are responsibly extracted, efficiently processed, transformed into high-value products, professionally marketed, and supported by effective institutions.

One of the book’s key contributions is its examination of the paradox of Pakistan’s mineral economy, a country endowed with remarkable geological diversity but unable to fully realize the economic benefits of its resources. Pakistan possesses substantial deposits, including more than 297 billion tons of marble and granite reserves, 6.1+ billion tons of copper and gold deposits in the Tethyan belt, and significant resources of industrial minerals such as coal, gypsum, and barite. Yet, despite this resource base, the sector continues to operate below its potential due to limited processing capacity, weak value chains, inadequate certification systems, and insufficient integration with international markets.

A particularly valuable aspect of Carving Value is its analysis of the export performance gap. The book highlights that Pakistan’s mineral exports remain disproportionately low compared with its resource potential. Marble exports increased from approximately US$8.34 million in 2015 to US$13.25 million in 2023, granite exports reached around US$4 million in 2023, while gemstone exports stood at approximately US$6.25 million in 2023. These figures reinforce the author’s central argument that the future of the sector lies not simply in extracting more resources, but in building capabilities for processing, certification, manufacturing, branding, and global market access.

Another strength of the book is its institutional perspective. Drawing upon professional experience in sector development, the author highlights the importance of governance, finance, mechanization, technology transfer, and public-private collaboration. The book rightly identifies SMEs as the backbone of Pakistan’s stone sector while emphasizing their need for improved access to modern equipment, skills development, financing, and organized markets. The discussion on responsible mining further enhances the book’s relevance. Environmental sustainability, occupational safety, community welfare, and transparent governance are presented not as optional considerations but as essential foundations of a modern mineral economy.

Overall, Carving Valuenis more than a study of Pakistan’s stone and mineral sector; it is a strategic call for transforming resource ownership into economic capability. The book shifts the national conversation from “what resources Pakistan possesses” to the more important question of “how Pakistan can create value from those resources.” It is a valuable read for policymakers, investors, industry leaders, researchers, and all those interested in Pakistan’s journey toward industrial development and export-led growth. The electronic version of the book is available free of cost at www.zahidmaqsoodsheikh.com

—The writer is an institutional development and governance expert.

 

Get Alerts