Balochistan: Feudalism and underdevelopment

Balochistan Feudalism And Underdevelopment

BALOCHISTAN is Pakistan’s largest province, covering 43.6% of the country’s landmass. It shares borders with Afghanistan and Iran and has a 750-kilometre coastline along the Arabian Sea, close to the Strait of Hormuz, one of the world’s most vital maritime corridors. Despite accounting for only about 5.94% of Pakistan’s population, the province is exceptionally rich in natural resources, including oil, gas, copper, coal, chromite and marble.

Major energy reserves are found in areas such as Sui, Bolan and Kohlu, with Balochistan supplying a significant share of Pakistan’s gas needs. Yet the contradiction is stark: only 20 of the province’s 34 districts have access to gas. In some cases, communities living just four kilometres from the Sui gas fields remain without this basic facility. Despite its immense wealth, around 85% of the province’s villages remain trapped in poverty and neglect. For 78 years, Balochistan has struggled to translate its natural wealth into broad-based prosperity. Pakistan’s economic future is, therefore, closely linked to the province’s development. If its resources were managed transparently and utilized effectively, they could transform not only Balochistan but the socioeconomic fabric of the entire country.

Why, then, does the province continue to struggle? External actors, including India, have exploited internal grievances to fuel instability, but the failure of local leadership must also be examined. The traditional Sardari or tribal system has, in many ways, constrained political and social development. Its roots lie partly in the British colonial era, when the Raj adopted a policy of indirect rule. Tribal chiefs were granted titles such as Nawab and Sardar, along with land and financial privileges, in return for loyalty and the maintenance of order. This created a powerful political and administrative elite whose influence has survived long after independence.

After 1947, many tribal chiefs translated their traditional authority into modern political power, becoming governors, chief ministers and federal ministers. Baloch politics has consequently remained heavily influenced by a small number of powerful families. While some argue that the Sardari system preserved tribal traditions, others see it as a barrier to modernization. What is difficult to deny is that power, land and resources have historically remained concentrated in relatively few hands, limiting the emergence of a strong middle class and leaving many ordinary citizens without quality education, healthcare and effective political representation. Balochistan’s political history is itself complex. At independence, the territory was not a single province but comprised different entities, including British Balochistan and the State of Kalat. The present province took shape in 1970 following the dissolution of One Unit. This history continues to influence its politics and its often-tense relationship with the federal government.

Education provides another example of the province’s challenges. At independence, schools were scarce and literacy extremely low. Although the education network has expanded considerably, with universities and colleges established across the province and various government and military-supported initiatives, many remote areas still lack adequate educational facilities. The Pakistan Army and Frontier Corps have contributed to infrastructure, scholarships and educational opportunities, but these benefits have not reached every community equally.

The role of influential tribal families, including the Bugtis, Marris and Mengals, remains controversial. Some leaders became prominent participants in the federal political system, while others chose resistance against the state. Critics argue that sections of the tribal elite failed to prioritize education, economic development and social reform in areas under their influence. Their response, however, is that the state extracted Balochistan’s resources without ensuring that local communities received a fair share of the resulting wealth.

The political careers of figures such as Nawab Akbar Bugti and Akhtar Mengal illustrate this complexity. They were both participants in Pakistan’s political system and symbols of the friction between Balochistan and the Centre. Grievances have also been intensified by the painful issue of enforced disappearances, which remains a major source of mistrust. Ultimately, the ordinary Baloch citizen has paid the highest price. Insurgency and separatist violence have discouraged investment and obstructed development, while the common people continue to face poverty, unemployment and inadequate services. If influential families have controlled political power and resources for generations, they must also answer why lasting foundations for development were not established. At the same time, blaming the Sardari system alone would be equally simplistic. Federal policies, unequal resource distribution, governance failures, security problems and historical grievances have all contributed to Balochistan’s predicament. The province needs neither a blame game nor competing narratives, but an honest assessment of the responsibilities of all stakeholders.

Balochistan is too important to remain marginalized. Its resources, coastline and geographical position make it strategically vital for Pakistan’s economy, regional trade, energy security and access to the Arabian Sea. The answer lies not merely in security measures or isolated development projects but in a comprehensive political, social and economic rethink. This means strengthening local government, ensuring transparent governance, sharing resources fairly, expanding quality education, creating employment opportunities and upholding the rule of law equally for all. It also requires genuine political participation and a greater sense of ownership among local communities.

Ultimately, Balochistan’s story is not simply one of deprivation despite natural wealth. It is a story of trust, governance and partnership. If the federal government, provincial leadership, tribal elites and the people can learn from the bitterness of the past and work towards a shared future, Balochistan can transform its own destiny and become one of the strongest pillars of a prosperous Pakistan. Realizing this has never been more important.

—The writer is Chairman, Tehrik Jawanan Pakistan.

([email protected])

Get Alerts