WHEN a mother cannot find medicine for her sick child, a graduate cannot find work, and a family lacks clean drinking water, provincial boundaries are hardly their greatest concern. Their question is simpler: when will life improve? Yet Pakistan’s debate over creating new provinces is dominated by political positions rather than the practical needs of those who would live within them, especially families struggling with rising costs and unreliable public services. Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s November 17 speech at the Karachi Press Club sharpened this de-bate. Opposing the forced division of Sindh, he stressed constitutional procedures and public consent. Supporters of new provinces argue that distant, neglected regions lack influence over decisions made in provincial capitals. Both arguments deserve examination. Neither should escape the essential test: will ordinary citizens receive better services, fairer opportunities and more responsive government?
A new province might bring administrators closer to communities and give neglected regions greater representation. That possibility deserves serious consideration, particularly where travelling to a provincial capital imposes costs families cannot afford. But new assemblies, secretariats and governors’ residences cost money. They do not automatically create jobs, improve hospitals or put teachers in classrooms. If authority remains concentrated in a few offices, deprivation will merely acquire a new address.
Defenders of existing borders must also offer more than appeals to history and identity. Cultural ties matter, but people in remote districts deserve the same access to basic services as those in provincial centres. Anyone opposing division should explain how the present system will correct regional inequalities.
Pakistan already has a constitutional route to more responsive governance. Article 140A requires provinces to devolve political, administrative and financial authority to elected local governments. The 18th Amendment expanded provincial autonomy, but meaningful devolution often stopped at provincial capitals. According to a July 2026 World Bank report, local governments’ share of total public expenditure fell from approximately 10 percent in 2005 to below 5 percent in 2024. That is a troubling measure of how little power has reached communities.
Why should residents need provincial intervention for drainage, drinking water or local roads? Elected councils need predictable funding, skilled staff and clear authority. Provincial administrations should set standards and monitor performance; local representatives should deliver services and answer for failures. Stronger Provincial Finance Commissions could allocate funds according to population, poverty, remoteness and need, rather than political influence. Funding should arrive on schedule, not depend on political favour or officials’ discretion. Accountability must be visible. Every district should publish accessible annual figures showing functioning schools, medicines available in clinics, development funds released and projects completed. Public hearings, independent audits and deadlines for responding to complaints would allow people to challenge poor performance. Women, minorities and re-mote communities must be heard when spending priorities are set. These reforms can begin without redrawing a single boundary. They would also give voters reliable evidence when judging elected representatives. Those advocating new provinces owe the public an equally detailed plan. What will the transition cost? How will revenues, debts, civil-service posts, water rights and public assets be divided? What measurable improvements can residents expect within five years? Proposed borders must respect linguistic, cultural and economic ties. Article 239(4) requires a two-thirds majority in the affected provincial assembly for a constitutional amendment changing provincial limits; a referendum alone cannot replace that requirement. An independent assessment should compare restructuring with properly empowered existing districts. Security adds urgency to these questions. In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the October 11 imposition of emergency measures and governor’s rule generated political and constitutional objections. Whatever the administrative arrangement, residents need safer markets, uninterrupted schooling and support for families affected by violence. Extraordinary powers must be judged against clear security goals, civil liberties and independently verified, publicly reported results. In Balochistan, lasting improvement requires both security and meaningful local participation. Communities should see a fair share of natural-resource benefits, jobs, functioning schools and healthcare. Major projects cannot be judged solely by their size; their value lies in the opportunities they create nearby. Women, young people and local representatives should help determine priorities, not merely endorse decisions already made.
Pakistan needs a public-service agenda that outlasts governments: functioning primary schools, reliable basic healthcare, safe water and credible pathways from training to employment. For every commitment, publish the budget, deadline, responsible institution and results. Citizens should be able to compare what was promised with what was delivered.
Ultimately, the issue is not how many provinces Pakistan has, but whom its governance serves. Without such safeguards, restructuring may simply create more governors, chief ministers, ministers, advisers and privileges for established political networks, while public hardship remains unchanged. Pakistan’s leaders must decide: do they want to redraw the country’s map, or change the lives of the people who live within it?
—The writer is Barrister, Solicitor & Notary Public, Usman Law Professional Corporation, based in Canada.


















