Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Fatima Asghar Post-Mortem reveals How Torture at FIA Director’s House led to her Death

Fatima Asghar Post Mortem Reveals How Torture At Fia Directors House Led To Her Death

ISLAMABAD – Islamabad’s minor housemaid Fatima Asghar was supposed to be studying, dreaming, and enjoying her childhood. Instead, her life ended in tragedy inside the home of FIA Gujranwala Zone Director Muhammad Bin Ashraf in Islamabad.

A day after the Islamabad Police action, her preliminary post-mortem report shows a grim picture of repeated torture, severe injuries and fatal blood clots that ultimately claimed her young life. The disturbing findings from her preliminary autopsy raised serious questions about the alleged brutality she faced inside the official residence of a senior Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) officer in the capital.

The investigators uncovered evidence of violence, recovered objects suspected of being used in the assaults and examined conflicting statements from two arrested suspects.

Autopsy Reveals Prolonged Torture

The post-mortem findings suggest that Fatima did not die from single injury. Instead, repeated physical trauma allegedly triggered a series of medical complications that eventually proved deadly.

The girl’s body showed extensive injuries, including severe bruising, swelling and inflammation. Initial medical accounts also mentioned suspected burns and more than 20 injury marks. The trauma reportedly caused blood clots to develop in her body. These clots led to thromboembolism, a dangerous condition in which a clot travels through the bloodstream and blocks a blood vessel.

The resulting complications allegedly caused cardiopulmonary arrest, leaving her heart and lungs unable to function. While the preliminary findings strongly indicate serious physical trauma, investigators are awaiting the final forensic report to establish the exact cause of death.

As investigators attempted to piece together Fatima’s final days, police recovered an electric iron and a wooden stick suspected of being used to inflict injuries on the minor. The discoveries added troubling dimension to the investigation, particularly after earlier medical observations identified marks that some accounts described as possible burns.

Police also reportedly secured CCTV footage from the residence. Investigators believe the recordings may provide crucial evidence regarding the treatment Fatima received before her health deteriorated. The recovered objects and recordings are being examined to establish their connection to the alleged violence.

One of key developments emerged during police questioning, when Qari Ali Raza, a co-accused who reportedly worked as a religious teacher at the residence, allegedly implicated Afshan Ali, the wife of the FIA director. Ali Raza told investigators that Afshan regularly punished Fatima by striking her with a wooden stick.

He reportedly disclosed that the girl’s condition eventually became so serious that she was taken to a dispenser at the Police Lines medical facility.\ After examining Fatima, the dispenser allegedly warned that her health was deteriorating rapidly and advised that she be shifted to a private hospital for urgent medical care. She was shifted to hospital in critical condition but could not survive.

Afshan Ali however rejected allegations that she brutally assaulted Fatima, presenting a different version of how the minor came to live at the residence. She maintained that the girl was studying the Holy Quran and was not employed as a domestic worker.

Afshan reportedly admitted to occasionally disciplining Fatima with a stick over educational matters but denied subjecting her to severe violence or causing burn injuries. She also raised the possibility that the girl had ingested fertiliser, although the preliminary medical findings have not substantiated that explanation.

Following her death, Shams Colony Police registered FIR No. 619/26 under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code on her father’s complaint. Judicial Magistrate Naima Iffat granted investigators four days of physical remand for both accused, despite a police request for eight days.

Afshan has also been reported to possess Canadian citizenship, although her nationality has no direct bearing on the allegations being investigated.

The allegations have also triggered administrative consequences for FIA Gujranwala Zone Director Muhammad Bin Ashraf. He was removed from his position and directed to report to FIA Headquarters in Islamabad as the investigation into Fatima’s death intensified. Reports indicate that the officer was abroad at the time of the incident, having travelled for Umrah followed by an official assignment.

His reported absence and subsequent removal do not establish his involvement in the alleged crime. However, the fact that the incident occurred at the official residence of a senior law enforcement officer has brought additional public attention to the case.

Islamabad Police seize Sticks, get CCTV in Death Probe of Fatima Asghar

Get Alerts