Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Who leads our schools?

 

GO to any government school in Pakistan and ask the headteacher what she did today. She will mention the attendance register, a salary query, a visiting monitor, a broken fan and a letter from the district office. She will seldom mention teaching. We have built a system in which the person responsible for a school works as its clerk. This matters more than it appears. Research across many countries finds that, among the things a school controls, leadership is second only to classroom teaching in its effect on what children learn. A good head lifts every teacher in the building. A head buried in files lifts none.

The country does not lack a description of the job. In 2023, the Federal Education Ministry and the British Council launched national standards for school heads. They say what the research says: a head exists to improve teaching and learning. The trouble is that nothing in the way we choose, train, pay or judge headteachers asks them to do it. Consider how a head is made. Most reach the post through seniority, after years in the classroom and a short course at best. They are then judged on enrolment, attendance and the state of the boundary wall. A head who spends her morning on files is safe. One who spends it at the back of a weak teacher’s class must explain the unanswered letters.

The chain of command completes the picture. The head answers to the district office and the district office to the provincial secretariat. Nobody in that chain answers to the classroom, so the correspondence always wins. A useful mirror comes from an unexpected place. The National Association of Elementary School Principals in the United States sets out six standards in its guide, Leading Learning Communities. American schools have little in common with ours, but the central idea travels well: the principal is the lead learner of the school and the budget, the timetable and the staffing must follow the teaching. Four of its demands show what we fail to ask.

The first is time for teachers to learn from one another. The guide describes a principal in Ohio who rearranged the timetable so that teachers could meet while pupils were at art or physical education. No rule stops a Pakistani head from doing the same. What stops her is a monitoring regime that marks down every hour a teacher is not standing before a class. The second is data. Punjab has gathered attendance, enrolment and facilities figures on tablets since 2014, and a few school systems count so carefully. Yet the numbers travel up to the secretariat and rarely come back to the one person who could act on them. In a Texas school, the guide describes, teachers look at their results and ask, “So what?” Our heads are seldom given their pupils’ learning results in a usable form, and are never asked that question.

The third is knowing the children. In a single Lahore classroom, pupils may speak Punjabi, Urdu, Pashto and Saraiki at home and meet their textbooks in yet another language. In rural Sindh, a girl may be the first in her family to sit at a desk. The guide asks principals to examine their own assumptions about the families they serve and to help teachers do so. Our heads are handed a curriculum and told to deliver it, whoever walks through the gate. The fourth is parents. Every province has school councils on paper, though many hardly meet. The guide treats the community as a resource; one of its schools, in Hawaii, built working ties with a naval base and a carpenters’ union. Our heads learn to treat the community as a risk, because parents arrive with complaints and the local notable with a transfer request.

Closing the gap needs three decisions. The first is to free the head to lead teaching. Larger schools need an office manager for the registers and the correspondence. The second is authority. A head needs a real say over the school’s budget and some say over its staff. One who cannot move a teacher, who will not teach, is a head in name only. The third is to change who gets the chair and how she is judged. Selection should rest on merit, shown by the ability to improve teaching, with seniority as one factor among several. Training should be a year of coaching and peer visits in place of a few days in a hall. Appraisal should ask what children learned and how teachers improved.

Some will object that heads cannot be trusted with such power. The objection has it backwards. We withhold authority, then blame heads for results they had no means to change. Authority and accountability must arrive together and a head, who is given both and still fails, can be replaced. Two further steps would make these changes last. The universities that prepare teachers should prepare leaders too. And the 2023 standards need what they now lack, a link to promotion and appraisal, so that ignoring them carries a cost.

The stakes are plain. More than 25 million children are out of school and the World Bank estimates that over three in four ten-year-old cannot read and understand a simple text. Through two and a half years of a declared emergency, the talk has been of enrolment. Enrolment places a child in a building. Only leadership makes that building a school.

—The writer is Commoner from 44th Common Educationist — Founder of WHI Institute.based in Sargodha.

([email protected])

Get Alerts