Monday, November 16, 2026
Play Store.png
Observer Logo.webp
E-Paper
Monday, November 16, 2026

“Left home to buy vegetables, deported to Bangladesh”: Indian Muslim woman’s ordeal

Left Home To Buy Vegetables Deported To Bangladesh Indian Muslim Womans Ordeal

DHAKA – A 38-year-old Indian Muslim woman Shahida Fakir, who left her home in Mumbai on July 19 telling her young son that she was going out to buy vegetables, has ended up in a village in Bangladesh after allegedly being detained and forcibly deported by Indian authorities.

More than three months after her disappearance, Shahida is now living in Satkhira, a village in Bangladesh, despite maintaining that she and generations of her family have always been Indian citizens.

Speaking about her ordeal, Shahida said plainclothes officials detained her, seized her mobile phone and took her away in a vehicle.

“Someone grabbed my hand from behind and ordered me to get into a vehicle,” she recalled.

She said her phone contained copies of her identity documents, but she was not given an opportunity to produce them before being taken across the border. Court records indicate that the officials involved in her detention belonged to the Mumbai Police Crime Branch.

Shahida is among several people who have faced detention, deportation or citizenship investigations following India’s revised electoral rolls. Many affected individuals claim to possess Indian identity papers and family records, while their parents and siblings continue to appear on electoral lists.

The developments come amid an intensified campaign by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government to identify and deport people suspected of living in India illegally. Bengali-speaking Muslims have increasingly faced scrutiny, with several being labelled Bangladeshi nationals and sent across the border, including people who claim to have evidence of Indian citizenship.

The controversy has raised concerns over the connection between electoral roll revisions and the government’s wider drive against suspected undocumented migrants. Removal from an electoral register, however, does not by itself establish that an individual is a foreign national.

Left Home To Buy Vegetables Deported To Bangladesh Indian Muslim Womans Ordeal

According to figures cited in the report, approximately 130 million names were removed during India’s nationwide electoral roll revision, marking the largest such exercise in the country’s history. Muslims, India’s largest religious minority, have reportedly been disproportionately affected.

Human rights organisations have repeatedly raised concerns about discrimination against Muslims since the BJP came to power in 2014, accusing the government of policies that marginalise the community. The BJP has rejected allegations that legitimate Indian citizens are being targeted.

West Bengal witnessed one of the most extensive exercises, with around nine million names removed ahead of state elections earlier this year. According to Kolkata-based Sabir Institute, Muslims accounted for nearly 70 per cent of the 2.7 million names excluded following a more detailed verification process, despite constituting approximately 27 per cent of the state’s population.

The BJP subsequently won the elections, forming its first government in West Bengal.

Sabir Ahmed, founder of the institute, said public dissatisfaction with the ruling party was an important factor in the election outcome, but the removal of names from electoral lists had also significantly influenced the results.

Court documents show that Shahida was among 149 people deported to Bangladesh during the operation after authorities classified them as Bangladeshi nationals.

Shahida said she had never imagined being sent to Bangladesh, insisting that her home, grandparents and generations of her family were rooted in India.

Her husband, Juman, is now pursuing legal action on her behalf. The case is among hundreds of thousands of petitions filed against the removal of names from West Bengal’s electoral rolls.

In August, Shahida’s family approached India’s Supreme Court, arguing that exclusion from electoral lists could not determine a person’s nationality and that she could not lawfully be deported on the basis of unverified official claims.

Family records reviewed by the news agency reportedly show that Shahida’s parents and grandparents had been listed on electoral rolls in Swarupnagar, West Bengal, since India’s first general elections in 1952. Their names also appeared in the electoral registers of 2002 and 2003, records considered significant under the latest revision criteria.

Shahida’s own name had reportedly appeared on West Bengal’s electoral rolls since at least 2008, a fact supported by her voter identity card reviewed during the investigation.

However, Mumbai’s Foreigners Regional Registration Office told the Calcutta High Court that Shahida had produced a Bangladeshi birth certificate during questioning and failed to provide credible documentary evidence of Indian citizenship.

She disputed the claim, saying officials had confiscated her mobile phone and denied her the opportunity to present copies of the documents stored on it.

Under Indian law, citizens are not required to carry original identity documents with them at all times, adding another dimension to the legal dispute over her detention and deportation.

Get Alerts