THE Republican Party has lost its majority in the US Senate and House of Representatives. Some political commentators are satirically suggesting that, instead of regime change in Iran, regime change has taken place in the United States. However, a change in political power or parliamentary majority through elections is not regime change.
The American constitutional system has functioned for nearly two and a half centuries. The US Constitution was drafted in 1787, ratified in 1788 and came into effect in 1789. Under this system, the President serves a four-year term, members of the House of Representatives serve two years, and Senators serve six years, with approximately one-third of Senate seats contested every two years.
Midterm elections do not determine the presidency. Instead, they elect members of Congress and other public officials. Their results are also widely interpreted as an expression of public opinion regarding the President’s policies. Even if the President’s Party loses its congressional majority, the President remains in office but may face difficulties passing legislation and securing approval for the federal budget.
This is a fundamental feature of American democracy: a President completes the constitutional term regardless of whether his party controls Congress. There is no need for a revolution, military takeover or transformation of the political system. The constitutional framework continues to operate, allowing one party to replace another through elections.
Regime change, by contrast, refers to a fundamental transformation of a country’s political system, power structure or governing arrangements. It may involve the removal of a ruler through revolution, military intervention or foreign intervention, often accompanied by changes to the constitutional framework.
American political history offers several examples of peaceful transfers of power. Republican George W. Bush succeeded Democrat Bill Clinton, followed by Barack Obama, Donald Trump and Joe Biden. Trump returned to the presidency in January 2025 after winning the 2024 election. These transitions took place within the same constitutional framework. Another important feature of American democracy is the acceptance of electoral outcomes. Political opponents are expected to respect the people’s mandate, even when they disagree with the result. A leader’s popularity does not provide an automatic constitutional right to govern. Presidents must serve within the limits of the law and leave office when their constitutional term ends. Similarly, losing a congressional majority does not automatically remove a President from office.
What I particularly admire about the American democratic system is that an electoral defeat does not mean the end of a political party. The losing party can continue its political activities, examine its mistakes, rebuild public support and compete in the next election. Political competition should not be treated as a personal insult or a threat to the state’s existence.
The real strength of democracy does not lie in an individual leader’s popularity or a political party’s permanent dominance. It lies in institutions that allow political power to change hands peacefully, constitutionally and through the people’s votes. In a functioning democracy, governments change so that the system does not have to.
—The writer is Assistant Professor, Centre for Policy and Area Studies, Institute of Business Management, Karachi.


















