DR Abdul El-Sayed, the newly-elected US Senator from Michigan, has made history as the first Muslim elected to the United States Senate. An American of Egyptian descent, his success is a matter of pride for many Muslims. However, his recent remarks placing Pakistan alongside Israel in a discussion of American military aid deserve attention. In an interview with NPR on November 4, El-Sayed questioned military assistance to Israel, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Jordan and Pakistan. He argued that American taxpayers’ money should be spent on healthcare, education and infrastructure at home. Fair enough. Every government should look after its own people. But before questioning military assistance to Pakistan, should the Senator-elect not ask why America needed Pakistan’s cooperation in the first place?
In 1979, when the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan, America, together with Saudi Arabia, supported the Afghan resistance. Pakistan became a key partner in America’s Cold War strategy, providing logistical support and opening its doors to millions of Afghan refugees. When the Soviets withdrew in 1989, America celebrated its victory and moved on. Pakistan could not. The refugees, weapons and militant groups remained. American nuclear-related sanctions followed in 1990. Pakistan’s tragedy is that it became indispensable to America in times of war and dispensable in times of peace. In 2009, the then-US Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, admitted that America’s policy towards Pakistan had been inconsistent. She acknowledged America’s role in supporting the Afghan Mujahideen and its subsequent disengagement.
The Taliban emerged later from this troubled environment. Pakistan also made serious mistakes, including its support for the Afghan Taliban. But responsibility for this history cannot be placed upon Pakistan alone. Then came September 11, 2001. Nearly 3,000 innocent people were killed in terrorist attacks on America. Not a single one of the 19 hijackers was a Pakistani national. Yet Pakistan was once again asked to join an American war. President George W Bush declared: “Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists.” Former President Pervez Musharraf later claimed that Pakistan had been threatened with being bombed back to the Stone Age if it refused to cooperate. American official Richard Armitage denied making that threat, but the pressure on Pakistan was real.Pakistan joined the War on Terror, provided military and logistical support, shared intelligence and fought terrorist groups.
While America fought its war thousands of miles from home, Pakistan fought its consequences within its own borders. Tens of thousands of Pakistanis lost their lives. Schools, mosques and markets were attacked. Families were displaced. Who can forget the innocent children killed at Peshawar’s Army Public School in December 2014? According to Pakistan’s Economic Survey 2017–18, terrorism-related economic losses amounted to approximately $126.79 billion over 17 years. The Senator-elect wants American money to build American schools. Did Pakistanis not want the same for their children? Our economic difficulties also reflect corruption, poor governance and wrong economic decisions. But decades of conflict made these problems worse, reduced development opportunities and increased our dependence on foreign borrowing.
There is another important distinction. Pakistan received American military and civilian assistance, but approximately $14.57 billion came through Coalition Support Funds. These were reimbursements for expenses incurred in supporting American-led military operations. Such payments were not simply charity. Pakistan was providing services that America needed. While reimbursements and economic losses cannot be directly compared, both figures help explain the financial burden of this partnership. What particularly prompted me to write this article was El-Sayed’s inclusion of Pakistan alongside Israel. His opposition to military aid for foreign countries is understandable. His criticism of Israeli military actions in Gaza and his support for Palestinian rights also deserve recognition. But Pakistan and Israel have very different histories. Pakistan helped America fight its wars and suffered the consequences at home. Israel, meanwhile, has received substantial American military support for decades, including under an agreement providing $3.8 billion annually.Israel’s occupation of Palestinian territories, settlement expansion and military actions in Gaza have caused immense suffering and contributed to wider regional instability. It also faces genocide allegations before the International Court of Justice, which Israel denies.
Pakistan’s military partnership with America was largely shaped by Washington’s strategic needs in Afghanistan. Israel’s partnership has developed around different American interests in the Middle East. El-Sayed has not accused Pakistan of the same actions as Israel. Nevertheless, discussing military assistance to both countries without recognizing these differences overlooks an important part of history.The same international laws should apply to every country. But their histories and responsibilities are not identical. Mr Senator-elect, Pakistan is not asking you to overlook its mistakes. It is asking you not to overlook America’s. When Washington needed Pakistan, its message was clear: either you are with us or against us. America has every right to reconsider its foreign aid. What it does not have is the right to erase the history of a partnership for which Pakistan paid such a heavy price.
—The writer is a commentator on geopolitical and economic affairs.


















